Decide Whether to Hire

Before a job advert: what a person really costs, how many jobs a month you now need, and whether the work is actually there.
What you end up holding
“A number-backed yes or no, instead of hiring out of exhaustion and finding out in month three.”
The workflow — 4 steps
- 1Open What an Employee Really Costs →
Calculate the fully loaded cost — wage plus FICA, unemployment tax, workers' comp and benefits.
Typically 1.25-1.4× the wage. A $20/hr hire is a $26/hr decision.
- 2Open Break-Even Calculator →
Recalculate your break-even with payroll in it.
Payroll is fixed and work is not. That gap ends more growing trade businesses than slow months do.
- 3Open Cost Per Lead & Per Job →
Check whether your lead flow can actually feed another pair of hands.
Hiring into a thin pipeline turns a busy problem into a payroll problem.
- 4
Settle employee versus contractor in writing before anyone starts.
The tests turn on control. Misclassification is back taxes, penalties, and an uninsured injury claim.
Satisficing Under Exhaustion
“Decision makers can satisfice either by finding optimum solutions for a simplified world, or by finding satisfactory solutions for a more realistic world.”
— Herbert Simon, bounded rationality
Owners hire when tired, which is precisely when the search is shortest and the criteria loosest. Doing the arithmetic in advance converts an exhausted judgement call into a threshold you either clear or you don't.
Counting the Cost
“Suppose one of you wants to build a tower. Won't you first sit down and estimate the cost to see if you have enough money to complete it?”
— Luke 14:28
The passage is about half-built towers, which is what an unaffordable hire produces — someone let go at three months, worse off than before, and a business that now trusts its own judgement less.
Go deeper on this
A playbook ends in a document. These journeys change what you can do — same subject, more of it.
- 15Build Your Top Three Offers“What should I sell, and what should I charge for it?”11 actions →
- 16Get Found & Get Leads“How do I get customers who find me instead of the other way round?”11 actions →
- 18Grow Past Yourself“How do I grow without working more hours than exist?”11 actions →
- 21Your First Employee“How do I hire someone without getting it badly wrong?”11 actions →
www.actiontoolkit.com/playbooks/decide-whether-to-hire
